Ducati.ms - The Ultimate Ducati Forum banner

1 - 10 of 10 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
363 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Hi all.

I have a feeling the answer to this question is "NO" based on the very extensive threads on "oil blending" I just read but I was hoping to confirm.

Would it be all right to use a few quarts of one full synthetic from a manufacturer and one quart of full synthetic from another manufacturer if the viscosities are identical?

The "Oil Blending" threads appear to be dealing with mixing viscosities which I don't plan to do.

I'm guessing the answer is "NO", however, given that different detergents and base ingredients may vary from manufacturer to manufacturer and therefore, similar oils shouldn't be mixed.

Can anyone opine?

(Oils in question are: Spectro Platinum 4 10w-40 and Castrol Power RS Racing 4T 10w-40, both full synthetic).

Thank you!
-Curly
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
666 Posts
Yes you can mix them.
Up to a point, without problems.
If they're both API certified oils it is a requirement that they have no miscibility issues with each other.
That's to ensure we can top up our oil at any time without totally ruining the lubrication properties of the primary fill oil.

That still doesn't necessarily mean that one oils additive pack, won't clash with the other to some degree.
And or, cause a degradation of the performance of both oils.

Whether it makes any "real" difference in the grand scheme of things.
We will likely never ever know;)

The only truly safe way to blend oil without compromising performance, is to keep with the same brand and type/basestock.
 

·
Come in Spinner :)
Joined
·
7,547 Posts
If I was hell bent on doing it I'd email both manufacturers and ask them.

.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,312 Posts
I would not do it. Buy enough Spectro to finish the job, it's the better synthetic of the two.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
666 Posts
Hi all.

I have a feeling the answer to this question is "NO" based on the very extensive threads on "oil blending" I just read but I was hoping to confirm.

Would it be all right to use a few quarts of one full synthetic from a manufacturer and one quart of full synthetic from another manufacturer if the viscosities are identical?

The "Oil Blending" threads appear to be dealing with mixing viscosities which I don't plan to do.

I'm guessing the answer is "NO", however, given that different detergents and base ingredients may vary from manufacturer to manufacturer and therefore, similar oils shouldn't be mixed.

Can anyone opine?

(Oils in question are: Spectro Platinum 4 10w-40 and Castrol Power RS Racing 4T 10w-40, both full synthetic).

Thank you!
-Curly

You are on the right track and there are a few facts to consider.
In simple terms.

1, One of the main things regarding API certification is that it is conditional for an oil to gain certification that it is "miscible with other oils". That only means it can be simply mixed readily with other oils that are also API certified.
It works out great for a top up on the run between services if the oil level is down too much and probably the only major benefit of API certification.
It doesn't make, nor can it make any guarantee about outright compatibility or performance in service.

2, In recent times, oil formulations have become quite complex in terms of diversity and complexity of base oils and additive packs and blends.
Although there is a fair bit of similarity in general terms, there can be no guarantees nor can anyone make an outright guarantee. It's impossible certainly in this day and age.
Gone are the days of only one or two major type of basestock with simple additive packs that share quite a lot of commonality.
API certification does help to provide some confidence in the miscibility department.
But we now have 5 distinct groups of oil basestocks with about 7or 8 different types of basestocks which can be totally different in terms of what's required to make a "fully formulated oil".

3, Whilst it's possible for a right thinking person to assume it's ok to even mix different viscosities to achieve a desired outcome with a franken brew if one wishes to play Tribologist at home with your ICE chemical reactor.
There are no guarantees as to the outcome of the resultant formulation.

As far as I know, there have been no major engine failures directly attributed to a bit of mixing of oils.

Certainly the performance of fully formulated oils varies greatly between them, and it is testament to the quality of the basestocks, additive packs and the ability of an oil company to blend a finished oil to a performance standard.
Blending forms a core aspect of the true art of finished oil production.

If you don't care much about the machine other than to keep it going well then mix away.
Otherwise for the very best results and confidence, try to stick with one grade and or type of finished oil within a given range of your chosen/favourite brand.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
666 Posts
Was searching for answer. I guess it's ok to mix it with my Motul oil into my bike with Spectro oil. (Of course, both synthetic and same viscosities)
On the balance of probability you are most likely correct in making this assumption:wink2:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
666 Posts
Good Lord, I've just realised that this thread is old and I've already responded to this thread ages ago.
Oh well, I suppose my responses are consistent.
At least it shows that I haven't totally lost my marbles (yet):surprise:

My apologies to the forum:(
 
1 - 10 of 10 Posts
Top