i had a '09 M1100 for 8 mths and subsequently traded it for '08 Hyper which I have had for 3 mths now.... I purchased both bikes new. The monster had 9 miles on it, my hyper had 5 at the time of delivery
Monster Pros (personal experience only)
- riding experience is great, I never felt like I was riding on the bike... all I could see was the road... look and thats where the bike goes... I felt very in-sync with the bike. I think, it goes... it was a great feeling
Monster Cons (personal experience only)
- riding ergonomics on the M1100 are very sport bike oriented. This is why I traded the bike in. the riding position may not be as aggressive as say an 848 or 1198, but it was definitely more than my Ninja 650r was. I tried to change this by switching seats, switching handlebars, and even lowering the pegs. In the end, I was felt I was trying to make the Monster something it wasnt... a bike with a "standard" riding position.
Monster/Hyper comparisons (again, personal experience only)
- engine... both bikes have basically the same platform, the DS1100. I have found that my Hyper revs a bit higher than the Monster did, not sure if its a difference in Cams, or what not, but I dont hit the rev limiter as often as I did on the Monster
- brakes... both bikes were base models, and my understanding is, the brakes on both are basically the same. Both work exceptionally well... I have no complaints
- riding position... Riding up on the tank on the monster will hurt (search Monster Balls to see why), but riding up on the tank on the Hyper is extremely comfortable and feels very agile.
Now its important to note, my M1100 was all but stock. I didnt change much on it other than add sliders and play with the ergos... On the flip side, my Hyper is not stock at all. The hyper has the Termi 2in1 race setup, 6.4 gall tank, DP Racing seat, windscreen, and lots of custom paint. As a result, its not a true apples to apples comparison, but I hope this helps.
Just remember, this is just my observations, and experiences. I expect others will be able to provide more to the conversation