~
Quote:
Originally Posted by CTarna
Can you explain your choice to dump V1 and any benefits you see using the Escort/Bel models?
|
It might be hard to explain, CT. It's really just kind of a "feel", a matter of preference more than anything else.
I've been fooling with radar detectors since the first Fuzzbuster's and Autotronics Snooper's back in the '70's and I guess that over all those years everybody develops their own likes and dislikes with the damn things. IMHO, Valentine V1's are *noisy*... Kind of like the ol' "Boy Who Cried Wolf" story. They are so overly sensitive that to me they go off all the frickin' time. Even if you spend time burrowing deep down in the control functions and infinitely adjust settings, etc. the damn things are still screaming and flashing arrows all the time. So much so that I can't honestly tell what's a real bogey or not half the time, and it seems like much of the time spent with a V1 is getting in and out of the gas constantly.
Honestly, I think the V1's ARE more sensitive and have a true range advantage over Escort/Beltronics offerings, but for me it's just not worth the continual beeping, brapping, and buzzing.
I've been driving with Escort's and BEL's products now for over a decade, and certainly they "false alarm" at times, too, but not with near the frequency V1's do. I am so used to how they work, their "filtering", etc. that I pretty much know when one of their alerts is for real or not, and I drive with them accordingly - and they have saved me countless times.
In addition, I also like how Escort/BEL try to stay on the leading edge of the art... Remote detectors like the 9500ci and STI-R, laser shifters, GPS and incorporating speed camera locations, etc. I like Mike Valentine. He's brilliant, but he seems to be mired a bit in time. You gotta' love him. He believes in his product and its architecture, but not all his software and firmware "updates" have been improvements. I think they are up to version 3.872, yet it seems like the "best" version is 3.813... At least according to some of the radar detectors forums:
http://www.radardetector.net/forums/index.php
http://www.radarreviews.net/forums/index.php
And once you have "updated" your V1 you can't go back...
BEL/Escort has "updates", too, like the recent BEL STI "ramping update", but they are few and far between, and they seem to always be an improvement. And now with the Escort 9500ci's, 9500i's, and 9500ix's you can connect them to the 'net and get firmware and software updates that way - and not have to send the unit back to the factory like you do with Valentine.
Sorry if the this has run a bit long, but I guess it just boils down to my liking the "feel" or "user experience" of the BEL/Escort units better than the Valentine. I also like that they seem to be leading the technological race in areas like red light and speed camera radar, along with GPS and auto-lock-out of false alarms. They are also the only outfit that has made the huge investment of time, money, and R&D to produce the world's only detector that is truly "undetectable" by radar-detector-detectors - the BEL STI and BEL STI-R. These are a godsend to true "professional" drivers, like truckers, in states where RDD's are used since radar detectors are illegal.
If you read those forums you will find folks who love their Valentine 1's just as much, so it definitely is a personal choice.
And now we even have a new player in the motorcycle radar detector race:
http://www.adaptivtechnologies.com/
From what I have seen these have tested well, and are definitely have some pretty trick features for motorcycle use. I might have to try out an Adaptiv one of these days...
Hope this helps.
Dallara
`